Millions of cards listed·0% seller fees·How it works
CardSynced
CardsGamesStoresSellTop SellersPre-ReleaseDeck BuilderNews
AI Checkout
HomeGamesMagic: The GatheringMurders at Karlov ManorA Killer Among Us

A Killer Among Us

Magic: The Gathering | Murders at Karlov Manor - Singles

United States marketplace listings with USD buyer pricing, shippable seller stock, and 14-day buyer protection.

A Killer Among Us - Magic: The Gathering Murders at Karlov Manor trading card
RarityU
Number167
Printed inMagic: The Gathering | Murders at Karlov Manor
Available57 items
From$0.26
TypeEnchantment

Format Legality

standard✓historic✓pioneer✓modern✓legacy✓vintage✓commander✓brawl✓

Seller Listings(57 available)Buyer price shown

Share:
SellerConditionCard priceStockAction
UStcgosaurusVerified Partner
NM
$0.2910
UStcgosaurusVerified Partner
NMFoil
$0.292
USCapeFearCollectiblesVerified Partner
LP
$1.501
CAOMGGamesVerified Partner
NM
$0.2622Unavailable
SGMythical1808Verified Partner
NM
$0.372Unavailable
AEZayedVerified Partner
NM
$0.4119Unavailable
AEZayedVerified Partner
NMFoil
$0.411Unavailable
Card Profileuncommon

About A Killer Among Us

A Killer Among Us from Murders at Karlov Manor is currently available from around $0.20. This panel brings together mana value, rules text, format signals, and set details in one place.

Enchantment

Mana Cost

{4}{G}Mana Value 5

Color Identity

{G}Green

Card Text

When this enchantment enters, create a 1/1 white Human creature token, a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token, and a 1/1 red Goblin creature token. Then secretly choose Human, Merfolk, or Goblin.
Sacrifice this enchantment, Reveal the creature type you chose: If target attacking creature token is the chosen type, put three +1/+1 counters on it and it gains deathtouch until end of turn.

Card Facts

Expansion

Murders at Karlov Manor

Current Floor

$0.20

Rarity

uncommon

Artist

Leesha Hannigan

Released

February 2024

EDHREC Rank

#23,232

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is A Killer Among Us worth?

A Killer Among Us is currently shown on Card Synced from about $0.20 for Murders at Karlov Manor. This is a live floor on active listings. For MTG singles, foil status and rarity generally have the biggest impact on spread.

A Killer Among Us currently shows mostly this printing in this view, which can help when comparing direct availability and condition.

Is A Killer Among Us legal in Commander?

A Killer Among Us is legal in Commander. It is also legal in Modern, legal in Pioneer.

Is A Killer Among Us legal in Modern, Pioneer, or Vintage?

This card can differ across formats. Card Synced shows a live legality snapshot from Oracle and updates it as rulings change. Use the legality table above to confirm full format details before buying.

Is A Killer Among Us on the Reserved List?

No. A Killer Among Us is not on the Reserved List. That can affect long-term scarcity and collector demand.

What is A Killer Among Us in-game text?

In game, A Killer Among Us is a Enchantment with text that starts: "When this enchantment enters, create a 1/1 white Human creature token, a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token, and a 1/1 red Goblin creature token. Then secretly choose Human, Merfolk, or Goblin.".

How popular is A Killer Among Us in Commander decks?

A Killer Among Us ranks #23,232 on EDHREC for Commander inclusion, which is a proxy for market demand and practical deck usage.

Buy A Killer Among Us on Card Synced

Looking to buy A Killer Among Us? Card Synced offers the best prices with 0% seller fees, meaning sellers keep more and can offer better prices. Every purchase includes buyer protection with a 14-day inspection period.

Plus, your Card Synced wallet balance can be spent at verified partner card shops worldwide, bridging online and offline card trading.

Searchers looking for A Killer Among Us legality or value usually care about the same things: current format status, available printings, and whether the card is seeing fresh demand from Commander, Modern, or Pioneer players. This page keeps those signals together.

Explore More Cards

More from Murders at Karlov Manor

Browse the full set

All Magic: The Gathering

Explore all sets

More U Cards

Same rarity, all sets

CardSynced

The marketplace that bridges online and offline card trading. Spend your balance anywhere.

0% seller feesEscrow protectedAI checkout ready

Marketplace

  • Browse Cards
  • Sell Cards
  • All Games
  • Top Sellers
  • Find Card Shops

Resources

  • Blog & Guides
  • Deck Builder
  • TCGPlayer Alternative
  • Cardmarket Alternative
  • Become a Partner
  • Store Portal

Support

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Returns & Refunds
  • Pre-Release Events

Card Synced is not affiliated with, endorsed, sponsored, or approved by any trading card game companies. All card names, logos, and images are property of their respective owners.

© 2026 Card Synced. All rights reserved.